Structure
他 + の + Noun
（その(1)） + 他 + にも(2)
Noun + の + 他 + にも(2)
Verb + 他 + にも(2)
（その(1)） + 他 + には(3) + Phrase［ない］
Noun + の + 他 + には(3) + Phrase［ない］
Verb + 他 + には(3) + Phrase［ない］
(1) この
(2) に、も、は、には
(3) に、は
Details
Register
Standard
About ほかに(も)・ほか(に)は
他に is regularly considered to be one of the more difficult structures to master in Japanese, so let's take a thorough look at it. Basically, 他 by itself just means 'another', or 'other'. に highlights 他 'another thing' as being the target of what comes next in any particular sentence. The possibilities are as follows:
他に - Another thing.
他に（も） - Even another thing (sounds less certain).
他に（は） - Was there another thing (focuses on something pre-existing, which someone may have forgotten).
他に（は） may be used in either positive or negative sentences, but it tends to appear in negative sentences more often.
Caution
Because 他に（も） focuses on the 'addition' of another thing, it cannot be used in negative sentences (with the exception of questions).
- 欲しいものは、その他にもない。There is also nothing else besides what I want. (Unnatural Japanese)
-
その他にも何か質問がありませんか？Besides that, are there no other questions? (Natural Japanese)
The reason this is acceptable in questions, but not statements, is due to the 'isn't it?' meaning that negative questions can have in Japanese (just like English). It is the equivalent of the following:
この他にもない - In addition to this, there is also nothing (sounds strange in English!)
その他にもないか - In addition to that, is there nothing else? (sounds normal in English!)
Synonyms
Examples
--:--
Get more example sentences!
Premium users get access to 12 example sentences on all Grammar Points.
他は？
Anything else?
いいえ、他はいりません。
No, I don't need anything else.
他は？
Anything else?
他の国に行ったことがありますか。
Have you ever been to any other countries?
他の方法がないかな。
I wonder if there is no other way. (another)
Self-Study Sentences
Study your own way!
Add sentences and study them alongside Bunpro sentences.
Online
There are no Online resources listed for 「ほかに(も)・ほか(に)は」.
You can . Resources are constantly updated, come back later to see new additions!
Offline
There are no Offline resources listed for 「ほかに(も)・ほか(に)は」.
You can . Resources are constantly updated, come back later to see new additions!
Track Resources!
Bunpro tracks all of the resources you’ve visited, and offers relevant bookmarks of physical books to help with offline tracking.
ほかに(も)・ほか(に)は – Grammar Discussion
Most Recent Replies (26 in total)
11442
What is the hint “inclusive” supposed to indicate on the prompt?
That concept is never addressed in the body of the grammar point, and in so far as I’ve found anyone using the terms in researching this grammar point, they use them in the opposite way. (that, は is exclusive, and も is inclusive)
他には（another “thing” separate from what was previously established)
他にも（another “thing” that is also part of what was previously established)
bilowik
I know I’m pretty late on this feedback, but I also struggled here for a while but the bit that made it click for was the bit in the caution that says “他にも focuses on the addition of something” and then going back to the other sentences made them all make sense. I think this mention of it being focused on addition should also be in the main section when talking about 他に(も) and would help differentiate the different uses.
I think why it’s not as effective only being down there bc it’s easy to overlook, the focus of that caution section is on negative sentences and why you can’t use も in them, rather than when you do use も. So for me, I overlooked this super helpful bit a good number of times, and once I really attached that meaning of “in addition” to も, it all clicked.
Thanks for taking the time to read my feedback! <3
soundjona
Got questions about ほかに(も)・ほか(に)は? Join us to discuss, ask, and learn together!
Join the Discussion